disclaimer. You recognize the name it ain’t mine"Piper? I am worry. We have really push her too far this time," said Prue as she pacing near the phone, waiting for it to ring. They haven't heard from Phoebe since last night. It's not natural, not for Phoebe anyway.

"Prue, stop worrying she is probably walking Ben, clearing her head and all." Replied Piper but deep down inside she is very worry.

"That is! I am going to her flat." Yelled Prue as she grab her jacket and storm down the driveway.
"Forgot something?" asked Piper as she hold Prue's car keys in the air, "And I am coming and that is that."

Soon they arrive at the block of flats. Prue look at Phoebe's window on the first floor. The light is not on. Panicking without waiting for Piper, she run to the stairs. She notice bumps in the walls as if someone hit them but she doesn’t care. She just want to know if Phoebe is alright and if she is not then she will blame herself for she is the one who shouted at her for crashing Piper's car.
"Prue! Wait for me!" Piper yell, it echo through the building but still Prue don't stop till she got to door number 13.

"Phoebe? Are you in there?" called Prue as she knock on the door. She press her ears against the door and listen. All she can hear is a dog crying.
At that moment Piper was just next to her.
"Have you got her keys? I can hear Ben crying!" said Prue as she shook Piper by her shoulder.

"No. But she does have one under the mat, just in case." Answer Piper, "But what if she in there, doing you know what?"

"It not like we haven't barge her in before!"

"Fair en.." before Piper could finish her sentence, the door swing and the sound of Ben howling came rushing out.

"Piper, that don't sound good." Prue said as she follow the sound of Ben howling.
She open the door, telling Piper to follow when she told her to. She gasp at the sight, Ben is covering with blood but why isn't Phoebe doing something? She creep a little bit closer, it not him who bleeding, it's her baby, her child, her friend, her sister.

"Piper…don't come in, it's bad." Sob Prue as she move the stray hair out of Phoebe's eye.

On the other side of the door, Piper couldn't wait any more, slowly she prepare herself for she might see but it didn't help. She just cry and scream at Phoebe to wake up.

"She won't. She is dead." Cry Prue as she pick up Ben who is confusing, why are they crying? Have his beloved master died for real? Are they sure it not just a game like they play before? Struggling in Prue's arms, he jump out. Hitting Phoebe on the face with his paws and then licking her like how he would in the morning when her alarm went off. But this time something is different, she isn't going to wake up. He look up at her sisters hoping they will do something but all they did was hugging each other, crying even Prue is.

The neighbour came and ring the police. Soon they came. One of the policemen starting to cover her up but then Ben suddenly bark and run to Phoebe, trying to wake her up. He want her.

"Ben. Come on. She not coming back." Hushed Piper, she sounds if she is unsure of herself. Ben just look up with a tear in his eye, he won't believe that his master is gone, not now, not ever. He is about to go back to her but then he felt Piper picking him and carry him out and away from her.

When they arrive at the house after a long silence ride, both sisters broke the news to their husbands.

They couldn't believe it mostly Ben and Prue.

The funeral was beautiful and sad. The sisters is crying and they are in shock, it not Phoebe. She wouldn't kill herself. Memories came through their heads, happy and sad ones. They have try make Ben come but he won't in fact he never left outside of Phoebe's door.

He stay there in hope that she will come back. Piper and Prue have try and show him that Phoebe is not coming back but it hard, he won't listen.

***3 years later***

Ben have died three years ago, a week after Phoebe's death. The vet said it is of broken heart.

Prue have a girl and named her after Phoebe. She is so like Phoebe that she swear that it is really her sister in her daughter's body.

Piper have a boy and a girl, she call the boy Ben after the dog and name the girl Becky, it was Phoebe's favourite girl's name.

Phoebe isn't forgot, she will always be in their heart forever.